Pirate 4x4 banner

1 - 20 of 33 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,234 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Alright I'm on the market for a set of 9" housings.. I think I've narrowed it down to either the spidertrax ultimate or the ruffstuff housing.. trying to stick around that price range..
What one would/did you buy and why?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,977 Posts
I bought an early production ruffstuff, and wouldn't again for my trail rig / cone dodger.

The center section is so wide, that it gets caught more than it should. Yes, there probably are strength advantages with the housing being that wide, but I don't think I need them. For a rear axle in a desert truck where rock clearance isn't as big of a deal - sure, probably a perfect axle.

Also, I'm not sold on the bump-bend 'round-ish' profile. In my front axle application, I have severely dented that in after making a poor choice dropping off a ledge. I didn't have the ruffstuff weld on skid plate, but it deformed a lot. My ring gear has self clearance the inside of the housing after the dent.

At the time I bought mine, Ruffstuff didn't have much figured out for front axle seals. I went through 5 or 6 different iterations, and ultimately have trail- gear inner axle seals and carriers installed, after die grinding the 1/2" faceplate from the backside, and installing different O-rings than trail-gear provided.

I also think the 3.5" .380 wall tube is a bit much for my use - .250 wall would probably be just fine.

My next front axle will be a Spidertrax or Diamond. Narrower center, both offer .250 wall tubes, and I'll be putting a skidplate on the bottom / front of the center section to add some extra metal where it might need it.

Food for thought anyway. Mine was also an EARLY production ruffstuff housing, like 2008/2009, so it may be different now.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,998 Posts
Not that I care, but why isn't Trail Gear being considered?
This. Their housings are the cheapest and just as nice. Ruffstuff housing is nice, but it's massive. If your not looking for a 4130 housing. Trail-Gear would be at the top of the list if price is at all a factor.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
12,576 Posts
This. Their housings are the cheapest and just as nice. Ruffstuff housing is nice, but it's massive. If your not looking for a 4130 housing. Trail-Gear would be at the top of the list if price is at all a factor.
And you can order them from Summit to get free shipping.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,625 Posts
Trail Gear would be at the top of my list as well, followed by spidertrax. I've also seen housings show up on the spidertrax outlet page. I bought an early ruff stuff years ago with a warped mounting face that was still unusable after ruff stuff machined it. I have since bought a Toyota housing frim them that was great and only wouldn't consider them now because the center is so big.

I'm currently building a currie housing and this is how it was sent out the door.

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,234 Posts
Discussion Starter #8
I bought an early production ruffstuff, and wouldn't again for my trail rig / cone dodger.

The center section is so wide, that it gets caught more than it should. Yes, there probably are strength advantages with the housing being that wide, but I don't think I need them. For a rear axle in a desert truck where rock clearance isn't as big of a deal - sure, probably a perfect axle.

Also, I'm not sold on the bump-bend 'round-ish' profile. In my front axle application, I have severely dented that in after making a poor choice dropping off a ledge. I didn't have the ruffstuff weld on skid plate, but it deformed a lot. My ring gear has self clearance the inside of the housing after the dent.

At the time I bought mine, Ruffstuff didn't have much figured out for front axle seals. I went through 5 or 6 different iterations, and ultimately have trail- gear inner axle seals and carriers installed, after die grinding the 1/2" faceplate from the backside, and installing different O-rings than trail-gear provided.

I also think the 3.5" .380 wall tube is a bit much for my use - .250 wall would probably be just fine.

My next front axle will be a Spidertrax or Diamond. Narrower center, both offer .250 wall tubes, and I'll be putting a skidplate on the bottom / front of the center section to add some extra metal where it might need it.

Food for thought anyway. Mine was also an EARLY production ruffstuff housing, like 2008/2009, so it may be different now.
Thanks for the input. That's actually why I asked I know a ton of stuff has been redesigned the last couple years and there is really no discussion on the new designs.

Not that I care, but why isn't Trail Gear being considered?
Honestly after having such terrible issues with the rock assault axles I just didn't even want to try them out with a 9. Haven't done to much research into them but I do know the new rock assault design is great so I guess I could possibly give them a thought.

This. Their housings are the cheapest and just as nice. Ruffstuff housing is nice, but it's massive. If your not looking for a 4130 housing. Trail-Gear would be at the top of the list if price is at all a factor.
Not looking for anything "race ready" so 4130 isn't that big of a issue. But I dont think ruffstuff is 4130 or spidertrax ultimate just the pro series.

Trail Gear would be at the top of my list as well, followed by spidertrax. I've also seen housings show up on the spidertrax outlet page. I bought an early ruff stuff years ago with a warped mounting face that was still unusable after ruff stuff machined it. I have since bought a Toyota housing frim them that was great and only wouldn't consider them now because the center is so big.

I'm currently building a currie housing and this is how it was sent out the door.

I've always respected your input over the years so I guess I could give trailgear a look over to see if it will fit my needs.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
12,576 Posts
If I replace the stock housing in my prerunner, I'm going spiderfrax or Currie. Nice housings, not huge, machined face, and fit a 10" ring gear if needed.
Again, not trying to be a TG stooge, but their housings fit 10" as well. My 9" housings are the only thing I've ever bought from them. They're still being built but so far I am happy with them. Welding, fit, and finish was very nice.







Also, if you buy a centered TG housing it comes with enough tube to cut down and make an offset housing to either side whereas some of the other brands don't. This gives you more contingency options later down the road if plans change as well as more leftover tube laying around that is a size you most likely wouldn't otherwise ever buy on its own.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,980 Posts
Trail Gear housings front and rear here as well. On the front I'm running the Spidertrax knuckles and c's. 10" gears front and rear with no grinding.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,998 Posts
If I replace the stock housing in my prerunner, I'm going spiderfrax or Currie. Nice housings, not huge, machined face, and fit a 10" ring gear if needed.
Trail-Gear has a machined face, not huge and fits a 10" gear.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,591 Posts
Diamond has my vote.

Brian is great to work with, will take the time to answer all your questions and provide suggestions to get an axle that is absolutely tits for your application.

I also like that the C's are welded on ensuring proper caster and a straight axle. Just bolt on your diff, inners, and other components and go.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,998 Posts
Diamond has my vote.

Brian is great to work with, will take the time to answer all your questions and provide suggestions to get an axle that is absolutely tits for your application.

I also like that the C's are welded on ensuring proper caster and a straight axle. Just bolt on your diff, inners, and other components and go.
TG will also weld the ends on. You can get a rear with the bearing pockets welded on, seals and 4340 35 spline shafts for $990. Nobody can tough that price.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,591 Posts
TG will also weld the ends on. You can get a rear with the bearing pockets welded on, seals and 4340 35 spline shafts for $990. Nobody can tough that price.
Sure, and that's great, but you are stuck with TG unit bearing ends (no options for anything else), and foreign shafts. I don't see an option for a complete front axle? As always, you get what you pay for. To each his own.

I personally won't buy anything TG, and I'm not stopping anyone but friends from doing it. That's all. OP is free to make his own call. :flipoff2:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
27,625 Posts
Sure, and that's great, but you are stuck with TG unit bearing ends (no options for anything else), and foreign shafts. I don't see an option for a complete front axle? As always, you get what you pay for. To each his own.

I personally won't buy anything TG, and I'm not stopping anyone but friends from doing it. That's all. OP is free to make his own call. :flipoff2:


:flipoff2:
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
8,998 Posts
Sure, and that's great, but you are stuck with TG unit bearing ends (no options for anything else), and foreign shafts. I don't see an option for a complete front axle? As always, you get what you pay for. To each his own.

I personally won't buy anything TG, and I'm not stopping anyone but friends from doing it. That's all. OP is free to make his own call. :flipoff2:
I would normally agree with "you get what you pay for". But I'd put TG made in the USA housings up against any of the other brands.

Yes their shafts, like most other are not made here. But they do have a lifetime warranty:flipoff2:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,591 Posts
I would normally agree with "you get what you pay for". But I'd put TG made in the USA housings up against any of the other brands.

Yes their shafts, like most other are not made here. But they do have a lifetime warranty:flipoff2:
I'd rather not break in the first place than deal with any kind of warranty, but again, that's just me.

Alright, enough of this bullshit...OP do what you want. You have plenty of places to burn a hole in your wallet now. :smokin:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,681 Posts
So do regular super duty unit bearings no bolt to these tg bearing pockets, that would seem odd.
 
1 - 20 of 33 Posts
Top