I have had Bestops, Kaylines and Eshans. I even had a Kayline factory softop replacement for a while. Eshan or any OEM top is 100000% better then even the best aftm. My Kayline OEM top would even seal up better than my hardtop. Eshan has great quality but it can take a while and you are looking @ $1000 by the time you get it. You will also need to paint the bows and frames. Not a bad deal for a great top. A bestop will run around $750 so it is not that much more for the OEM from Eshan.